Review by the American freelance reviewer, Erica Robyns

When I go into a collection of stories, I’m always a bit hesitant.  I usually rate each story individually, and those ratings are usually all over the place.  But I was blown away by this collection of tales.  I loved that each story was about being lost in one form or another, and yet each story was so unique!  Each tale was so wonderfully written. The pacing and plot of each were so well done and the characters were perfectly developed for their tale.  I really loved that a few of the stories came full circle, which I am a total sucker for.  Many of the stories also had twists that totally threw me for a loop or made me gasp.  More than once, when I finished a story that had a twist, I had to set the book down to really digest the story.

In many of the tales, the suspense kept me on the edge of my seat.  I just love when authors drop in a sentence like this: He looked over the brief introduction he’d just written for a talk he was due to deliver in London two weeks later ~ a talk he would never give.

Here are my reviews and quick notes for each story:

Blood Moon: I LOVED this story!  It was so suspenseful and unnerving as I anxiously waited to see what happened.  When the story came to its conclusion, I stopped and closed the book.  I wanted to stand up and clap.  I adore stories that are organized this way.  The paranormal twist was also fun!  5/5

The House Of Dreams: What an interesting idea!  I loved the premise of this one and that the story took a turn that I totally wasn’t expecting!  4/5

Mirage: Stories set in harsh environments always make me so nervous!  This one was so thrilling! Loved that there was a use of repetition that really put an awesome twist into the story!  5/5

The Kiss:This is definitely one of the best short stories [spoiler removed] of its genre I have read.  I loved the plot and the pacing!  It had just enough development to keep things interesting.  And the ending!!  5/5

Dust: I love stories where wishes are granted.  Especially when the result is rather spooky!  4/5

The Life and Purpose of Mr Henry Dodd: Trigger warning here: suicide.  I almost skipped this one because of the topic… but I’m glad I didn’t.  The end put a very interesting twist on things.  While I was reading, the story really got my blood boiling, but the end was worth it.  4/5

Outrage: WOW!  This one was so intense.  A bit repetitive, but it made sense with the situation.  I loved the ending!   5/5

Nemesis: Such a bittersweet tale!  The beginning of the story wasn’t for me, but the second half was great!  4/5

Jump: Trigger warning again here: suicide.  So dark!  3/5

It’s Only A Myth: I loved this one; it was in equal parts intriguing and terrifying!  I loved the references to myths throughout.  And what a great set up for the ending!  5/5

Flora’s Return: This story was so suspenseful!!  I loved the old fashioned horror vibe, and what awesome characters, both good and bad!  And such a spooky plot!  5/5

Fight or Flight: Wow!  This one totally hooked me.  How terrifying and heart-breaking.  5/5

The Encounter : Oh!  This one was equally terrifying and heart-breaking.  5/5

My final thoughts: This collection is absolutely incredible. I loved the majority of the stories so very much. There was only one story that was so-so for me simply because of the topic.

The stories in this collection are stories that will certainly be sticking with me for a long time. I will definitely be re-reading soon!

If you enjoy short stories of a wonderful variety that will keep you on the edge of your seat, you need to pick up this book.

Amazon reviews

Real life happenings plus fiction (Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 19 December 2018) Verified purchase

Really interesting and spooky tales.

Interesting and diverse tales (Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 14 November 2018) Verified purchase

I don’t usually like short stories, but the variety of different supernatural had me reading to the end of the book.

A Small Treasure Trove of Dark Fantasy

I found this collection to be every bit as good as the author’s 2007 first volume of supernatural short stories entitled Strange Tales In Fiction And Fact. I was again struck by how even several pages into a Howard story you can’t necessarily fathom to where he might have transported the reader by the end – or indeed just a few pages further on – such are the unexpected twists and turns. For example, I was twice absorbed in what I assumed was a straight-ahead detective or mystery tale, only to find myself suddenly jolted into something quite dark and otherworldly. The stories are varied in length, pace and time period, whilst subject matter traverses both the paranormal and what I might call ‘dark fantasy’. Many seemingly incidental phenomena in the stories cleverly have their significance revealed later on, and one can appreciate these stories for both the finer details and their larger, more subtle message. In most collections of shorts one usually finds a few ‘fillers’ that were not memorable, but for me every one was a page-turner leading up to a final, inspired twist.

The longest story here, ‘Flora’s Return’ is the author’s own sequel to The Innocents, the 1961 gothic horror film directed by Jack Clayton (based on the novella The Turn of the Screw by Henry James). I think anyone who enjoyed that BAFTA-winning classic will not be disappointed with this sequel, and thus has good reason to purchase this book – with all other stories being an added bonus! All in all, thoroughly enjoyable and highly recommended.

A fabulous, thought-provoking read, 3 April 2017

I got so much pleasure from reading these stories. Each one was like an escape into another world for me and I eagerly followed the journeys of all protagonists with keen anticipation for the outcome. I love all the twists, the different characters and the variety of themes relating to the supernatural. Reading each story was like watching a film, as they’re so visual. Many made my spine tingle, others made me smile at their hidden messages. I think the author did a magnificent job of creating different narrative moods and pacing the story-telling to suit the plots and I know I’ll return to these stories time and again. I highly recommend it.

This second collection of the author’s little gems is every bit as good as the first, 20 Jun. 2017

I challenge anyone to read the first few lines of one of Richard Howard’s short stories and to then resist the strong urge to continue reading, normally right through to the end in one sitting. This second collection of the author’s little gems is every bit as good as the first. His fluent, concise writing style draws you in, and like good film music, the writing soon becomes transparent, leaving you immersed in the plot, eager to discover more, just as if the action were happening to you, rather than you reading it.

Elaborately woven dreamscapes, vampires, ghosts, fears, horrors within and without – if you are a lover of classic British horror stories this will draw you right in, to a world where the role of Karma and the innate natural justice of the universe collide with the frisson of beautifully engineered horror and creeping terror.

Net Galley Reviews

“This is a collection of short stories that surprised me. They range from fantasy to contemporary time periods. Each story is in its own world. I forgot everything else with each short story I read. Not all stories do this for me, especially short stories all written by the same author. The twists in each story kept me reading and enjoying them! There were unusual supernatural stories, myths, and ghost tales. There are stories that aren’t scary but were still engaging to me. They are all somewhat dark. This is a book that could introduce short stories to those who enjoy reading novels. Don’t pass it by because it’s a short story collection!”

“Every story is intriguing and packed with something unusual, with characters that you can live vicariously through and supernatural elements that you could never have dreamed of. There were so many myths, legends and ghost tales that were brought into this collection. I actually enjoyed the cliff-hanger feeling that each story left me with because it made me go through a rollercoaster of emotions, and culminated in a dramatic ending that made me literally go ‘whoa’! Some of the longer stories could have used some more transition elements but other than that, I really enjoyed everything I read! Overall, this was a great experience for me, and I cannot wait to read more short stories!”

“This book surprised me. What it contains is a number of delightfully twisted little stories, that aren’t always scary, and there may have been one about time and a wish that went over my head, but were none the less fascinating and enjoyable to read. Do recommend for anyone who likes twists and a little bit of horror (at least the kind without gore). If I had any complaint about this book, it would be simply that it was not long enough for me, but then I’m greedy like that.”

“Some of these stories are really great! It’s rare to find a book of short stories where you like them all; some were definitely stronger than others. Worth a read, particularly if you enjoy short format.”

Review from ‘A Ghostly Company’ newsletter

I found Tales of the Lost very easy to read, by that I mean more Phillip Pullman than Martin Amis. It would be equally at home on the adult and the young adult shelves, which is not to decry the depth of the ideas contained within the book. The book contains 13 stories, always a good number for a supernatural collection, which vary in length from ‘Blood Moon’, 32 pages, to ‘Dust’ which takes up a mere 3.

***********************************************************************